Translate This Page

Malaysia Bank Swift Code

What is Swift code? Swift code is known as ISO 9362 and is a standard format of Bank Identifier Codes approved by the International Organiza...

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

The "Middle Income Trap"

I come across this article and thought it would be nice to share it out here to see what are other people's opinion on the Middle Income Trap that are facing by some of the developing nation like Malaysia currently.


China, Malaysia, Korea And the Middle Income Trap


I just learned a new term today that I know I will be using frequently in the future. The term is "middle income trap" and it crystallizes some of my previously discombobulated thoughts I have had regarding economic development. Let me explain.

This new term (for me) comes from a post by Michael Schuman on Time Magazine's Curious Capitalist blog, entitled, "Escaping the middle-income trap." The post focuses on how Malaysia's economic growth has been so consistently strong since World War II, yet has been slowing over the last few years and of how Malaysia just cannot seem to break into the league of developed nations. Schuman defines this "trap," as follows:



I returned a few days ago from Kuala Lumpur, the capital of Malaysia, where the talk of the town – well, at least among economists -- is the “middle-income trap.” What's that, you ask? A developing nation gets “trapped” when it reaches a certain, relatively comfortable level of income but can't seem to take that next big jump into the true big leagues of the world economy, with per capita wealth to match. Every go-go economy in Asia has confronted this “trap,” or is dealing with it now. Breaking out of it, however, is extremely difficult. The reason is that escaping the “trap” requires an entire overhaul of the economic growth model most often used by emerging economies.



The concept behind the “middle-income trap” is quite simple: It's easier to rise from a low-income to a middle-income economy than it is to jump from a middle-income to a high-income economy. That's because when you're really poor, you can use your poverty to your advantage. Cheap wages makes a low-income economy competitive in labor-intensive manufacturing (apparel, shoes and toys, for example). Factories sprout up, creating jobs and increasing incomes. Every rapid-growth economy in Asia jumpstarted its famed gains in human welfare in this way, including Malaysia.

However, that growth model eventually runs out of steam. As incomes increase, so do costs, undermining the competitiveness of the old, low-tech manufacturing industries. Countries (like Malaysia) then move “up the value chain,” into exports of more technologically advanced products, like electronics. But even that's not enough to avoid the “trap.” To get to that next level – that high-income level – an economy needs to do more than just make stuff by throwing people and money into factories. The economy has to innovate and use labor and capital more productively. That requires an entirely different way of doing business. Instead of just assembling products designed by others, with imported technology, companies must invest more heavily in R&D on their own and employ highly educated and skilled workers to turn those investments into new products and profits. It is a very, very hard shift to achieve. Thus the “trap.”

Schuman sees South Korea as "probably the best current example of a developing economy making the leap into the realm of the most advanced." Schuman sees Malaysia as a long way from making that same leap:

Malaysia, though, is quite far from where it wants to be. That's a bit surprising based on its remarkable recent history. Malaysia has been among the best performing economies in the world since World War II, one of only 13 to record an average growth rate of 7% over at least a 25-year period. The country has an amazing record of improving human welfare. In 1970, some 50% of Malaysians lived in absolute poverty; now less than 4% do. Yet Malaysians also feel that they've become somewhat stuck where they are. GDP growth has slowed up, from an annual average of 9.1% between 1990 and 1997 to 5.5% from 2000 and 2008. Meanwhile, other Asian economies have zipped by Malaysia. According to the World Bank, the per capita gross national income (GNI) of South Korea in 1970 was below that of Malaysia ($260 versus $380), but by 2009, South Korea's was almost three times larger than Malaysia's ($21,530 versus $6,760). Malaysia is getting “trapped” as a relatively prosperous but still middle-income nation.

Schuman does not see Malaysia making the leap. Its companies are not innovating. Its private investment is declining and it spends almost nothing on R&D. "If Malaysia is going to break the “trap,” it has to reverse all of these trends."

So what has made Korea so different from Malaysia?

Why has Korea jumped so far ahead? I think the reason is embedded in the different methods the two countries used to spur rapid growth.

Both countries relied exports to create rapid gains in income, but they did so differently. South Korea, from its earliest days of export-led development in the mid-1960s, had been determined to create homegrown, internationally competitive industries. Though Korean firms supplied big multinationals with components or even entire products, that was never enough – Korea wanted to manufacture its own products under its own brands. The effort was often a painful one – remember Hyundai's first disastrous foray into the U.S. car market in the late 1980s and early 1990s – but Korea is where it is today because its private companies have been working on getting there for a very long time, backed in full by the financial sector and the government.

Malaysia, on the other hand, relied much, much more on foreign investment to drive industrialization. That's not a bad thing – multinational companies provide an instant shot of capital, jobs, expertise and technology into a poor country. MNCs, however, aren't going to develop Malaysian products; that has to take place in the labs and offices of Malaysia's private businesses. But those businessmen have been content to squeeze profits from serving MNCs and maintaining their original, assembly-based business models.

I have for years viewed Korea as THE success story of Asia. In fact, whenever people tout China and act as though democracy is wholly incompatible with growth, I respond with Korea. You can see me making this point in this Commonwealth Club of San Francisco video of a "Doing Business in China" panel. Korea was at one time the second poorest country in the world, second only to Niger. Now, Seoul is more dynamic than Tokyo and Korea just continues to grow both economically and in terms of its political freedoms. Why is that? And why are countries like Malaysia and Thailand stuck in the middle ground? And what about China and Vietnam, will they be able to make "the leap?

Japan and Korea are important because they have spending power. Vietnam and Cambodia are important because they have very low wages. China is the most interesting because just three or four years ago, companies were going to China because of its low wages, but now, companies are going there to make money (mostly on the Coast) and going there to make things (more and more inland).

Where do Malaysia or Thailand fit into all this?

Malaysia and Thailand remind me a bit of the mid-size law firm. I can understand hiring the big firm for the big deal or the big case requiring a massive number of associates or legions of highly specialized partners. And I can understand hiring a highly efficient and focused small firm. But I rarely understand hiring the mid-sized firm, which usually tries to price itself along the same lines as the big firms, but without the corresponding depth or expertise. Why bother? And nothing against either Malaysia or Thailand, but I think many businesses have asked themselves this very question.


Source: China, Malaysia, Korea And the Middle Income Trap




What do you think?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Labels

Investment News share market bursa malaysia FBM KLCI market daily report stock stock market Brokers Report Malaysia Financial Management brokers call Personal Finance research report Financial Economy General stock investment Money Articles FBMKLCI Stocks market PublicInvest Research Budget Wall Street Update PublicInvest research report Wall Street KLCI oil & gas 1MDB Hong Leong Investment Bank research report Personal Opinion Dow Jones Issue US bursa Credit Card Debt Kenanga research report equity market kenanga research oil price politics ringgit Market Watch PPP klse najib property development Malaysia Weekly Highlights Nasdaq oil property thoughts EPF Hong Leong Investment Bank Research Income Tax construction Maybank Research Misc Money Master Najib Razak S&P 500 Index The Edge Financial Daily US stock market bank negara weekly weekly investment term China Companies in Focus Inflation Loan Rules Theedgemarkets business maybank plantation s&P 500 warren buffett Crude Oil Insurance MIDF research report Maybank IB research Retirement Planning Reuters business news finance global opinion spending stocks with momentum technology Bank Brokers Feng Shui OPEC Savings Wealth bear market currency financial services global market investing microsoft wallstreet 1 Malaysia Development Bhd 1Malaysia Development Bhd BNM International Reserves Billionaire Budget 2016 Commodity Disney Investment Term Malaysia News PCB Petronas Richest People STD Saudi Arabia bloomberg british american tobacco gaming sector low oil price media publicInvest russia share investment stock pick telecommunication top glove trading wallstreet update weakened Ringgit 2010 2016 Air Asia America Bad Debt Bill Gates Billy Toh Budget 2017 Calculation Chinese New Year Currency Exchange Education Fed Forex Gold IPIC Income Iran Kenanga Research research report Lembaga Tabung Haji MAS Macquarie research report Oil & Gas sector Quote RHB Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) Star Wars Star Wars: The Force Awakens US Fed hike affin hwang capital airasia analyst apple axiata bearish market business highlights construction & engineering consumer products dow jones industrial average earnings report equity expenses global bear market healthcare hup seng industries berhad inari inari amertron berhad interest rate learning malaysia airlines market news maybank investment bank oil and gas oil palm plantation oil prices opr overnight policy rate (OPR) s&P500 s&p satya nadella scandal thought thought of the day 2013 2014 Bank Negara reserves Broker Report Budget 2020 Cash Rebate Donald Trump Earn Financial Planning Financial World Forbes Global Competitiveness Report Global News Global semiconductor sales Goldman Sachs Good Debt How The Rich Get Richer IOI Corp Bhd India Intelligent Investor Interest Rates Linear Income M&A Securities Mahathir Malaysia Business Highlights Maybank 2 card P1 Passive Income Privacy Policy PublicInvest Bank research report REIT RHB Investment Research RHB Research Report RM SIA Sector review TA Research TM TPPA Telekom Malaysia Tun Dr Mahathir US news USD USD against MYR United States Wall Street Journal World Economic Forum Zeti airasia x airlines apple inc asset allocation automotive aviation sector azure banking sector bat beverage bonds box office brent crude budget 2015 bumi armada buy property cash consumer discretionary default developer electricity tariff hike engineering financial market global economy greece gst home hong leong investment bank house infrastructure iphone jobs kossan rubber industries macquarie equities research report malaysia Ringgit market close market updates mukhriz nadella new era for oil opinions pipeline services politic public bank random rate hike research retirement ringgit crisis sector update semiconductor semiconductor sales semiconductor sector shale producers share sime darby stock market. oil & gas industry tax technical analysis telco sector the edge weekly news world market 0% Easy Payment Plan 1MDB scandal 1mdb story 20 cents 2009 2011 29 minutes 3.25% 53 cost cutting measures 7-eleven 9 Things Rich People Do Differently Every Day ABNxcess AFP NEWS AMMB Abu Dhabi fund AirAsia X Bhd Alcohol AmInvestment Bank research report Amazon Ambank Aminvestment research report Ann Joo Ann Joo Resources Bhd Anwar Apple watch Asia Asian stock market Avengers BIMB Securities Research BJ Auto BP Plastics Holding Bhd BSI Singapore Bailout Banking and finance sector Benjamin Graham Biden Bio Osmo Book Borneo Oil Bhd CIMB CLIQ Energy Bhd CPO export tax CPO price CSI 300 Carlos Slim Carlsberg Cepatwawasan Group Bhd Charts China General Nuclear Power Corp China's bond market China's wealthiest man Christmas Circuit breaker Citibank Cash Back card Commodity Watch Credit Customer Service DSKH Holdings (M) Bhd Dagang NeXchange Bhd Datasonic Group Bhd David cameron Debt Status Deficit Deloitte Dividend Domestic news Dutch Lady Milk Industries Bhd E.U ECB EON Eastern & Oriental Bhd Eco World Eco World Development Group Bhd Edra Euro Europe Central Bank European Union Evergreen External Trade FPSO Genesis Fed rate hike Federal Reserves Federal rate Fitbit Fitbit Inc Gamuda Genting Malaysia Berhad George Kent (M) Bhd Global Competitiveness Index Global Issue Gordon Growth Greece exit Greed is Good Guan Chong Bhd Guinness HSBC Hasbro Hektar Reit Hiap Teck Ventures Bhd Highlights Hillary Clinton Hock Seng Lee Hong Leong Bank Bhd Hong Leong Bank Investment research report Hong Leong Bank Wise card Hong Leong Industries Bhd ICB IMF INTC IPO IPOs IT Ibraco Bhd Intel Corporation International Petroleum Investment Company (IPIC) Islamic Banking and finance sector Ismail Sabri JF Apex Securities JF Apex Securities Research Janet Yellen Jerasia Capital Bhd Junk KNM KNM Group Bhd KVMRT 2 Investment KWSP Keep Up With The Joneses Khir Toyo LHDN Leissner Lim Kit Siang Lucasfilm M+ online Market Wrap MARA MH370 MIDA MISC Bhd MLTA MPC MRTA MSN Money News Madza Malaysia Airports Holdings Malaysia Banking Malaysia Bond Market Malaysia fund Malaysian Palm Oil Board Malaysian Ringgit Mara Digital Store March CPO export tax Maxis Maybankard 2 Card Microsoft in the new era Millionaire Next Door Mistakes Motivation N2N Connect NAP 2014 NTPM Holdings Bhd Nazir Razak News Update News at a Glance Nikkei O&G OCBC OPEC war OSA Obama Office 365 Windows 10 Oil Watch PTPTN Packet One Parkson Paypal Perdana Perisai Petronas Chemicals Group Bhd Petronas Gas Bhd Pintaras Jaya Bhd Pioneer Natural Resources Co Power Practical ways on spending Prestariang Bhd Public Investment Research PublicInvestresearch report RBC Capital Markets RCP average poll of US election RGB International Bhd RHB Research RM crisis RM2.6 billion ROE Ranhill Holdings Bhd Rants Rating Raya holiday Recession Ringgit's volatility SEM SKB Shutters Corp Bhd SME segment SP Setia SRR Saizen REIT SapuraKencana Seacera Group Bhd Shale oil Sime Darby Bhd Simee Darby Singles Stimulus Plan Stock Selection for the Enterprising Investor Sunway Construction Bhd Superlon Holdings Bhd Swift Code TIME TMI TNB TOYOTA TRC Synergy Tan Sri Tony Fernandes Tax Reliefs Technorati Tenaga Tenaga Nasional Bhd The Citizens Declaration The Edge Weekly The Negative Side The New York Times Tim Cook Titijaya Land Bhd Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement Trump v Clinton Tsipras U.K UEM Edgenta Bhd UMNO UMW Oil & Gas UOA US Box Office US election US fed US manufacturing data US market US patent and trademark US prosecutors US stocks USA USD/MYR USEconomy Uchi Technologies Bhd Ultra-Rich Networth individuals UniFi United Kingdom Uob one card Versatile Creative Bhd W-8BEN WCT Holdings Wahid Wal-Mart Wall Street support Warren's Way Windows 10 Yak Yew Chee Yellen Yinson Holding abenomics aemulus affordable housing ahmad bashah ahmad zahid airline airports alibaba alternative investment aluminium asian market audit automobile azure machine learning bank negara malaysia below $30 a barrel berjaya auto bhd berjaya food bond market borneo utara highway brexit britain broadband budget 2018 budget revision bulk purchase of property bullish bullish market burse cloud computing cocoa coffee consumer staples consumption power cost of having a baby crane customer data debt investor deflation risk development downpayment for your home early election earnings per share economic outlook economic outlook 2016 economic sanction economics economy outlook ecoworld effective gross income egi election election budget electric utility electricity electricity bill electricity production endowment plan energy sector entertaiment eps essay european central bank eversendai eversendai corp export data family food beverage food services forecasts foreign-worker levy hike fundamental questions on retirement genting group genting plantation george soros global energy global stock market globetronic glove goldman great eastern group purchase of property has oil bottom? health higher price home business household & Personal product how low can ringgit drop? humor industrial package industry product interest internet investment income investment plan investment strategy iraq jack ma jack ma ready to take on the world jaks resources bhd japan jobless kimlun klci index knowledge land reclaimation work lawsuits life lifestyle lifestyle inflation liquefied natural gas (LNG) machine learning maintain buy malaysia government managing debt manchester united manufacture polyrethane product manufacturing marine engineering market closing market outlook markets mazda medical insurance metering microsoft earnings middle class monetary policy committee moneymaster mortgage movie negative nestle noon market offshore marine support services oil & gas services oil gain oil madness oil market oil production oil rally oil&gas oldtown opr hike patent petrol petrol chemical petroleum petronas gas pipeline project positive power generation power plant prime minister primus pacific private placement profitability ratios project reference property & infrastructure property development and investment putrajaya quantitative easing relative strength index (RSI) renewable energy reputational risk resources retail retailing retirement fund rhb research institute risk risks ruble salesforce sapurakencana petroleum savings for retirement scicom scientex scomi energy services bhd sector sell share markets share price shinzo abe shipbuilding shopping mall stagnation star publication (M) bHd starbucks statistics steel stock market bursa malaysia stock market investment stock price swiss swiss bank takaful tech technical indicator telco the malaysian insider the star thermo-vacuum form plastic packaging manufacturer time value money top gainers top losers trade volume index (TVI) traditional healthcare uchi tech umw holdings upstream oil & gas ursa malaysia value of compounding wal-mart effect warren buffet water related engineering wearable tech webe windows worldwide sales zecon